Membership Growth Strategies That Are Working Right Now
As a membership strategist, I share a lot about membership growth strategies from the point of view of someone who’s done it, since I’ve spent the past decade growing Styled Stock Society to over 10,000 members and tried pretty much every strategy out there along the way. But I also know there isn’t one right way to grow a membership, and what works for one membership owner doesn’t necessarily work for the next one (which is why I’m always nosy about what’s working for other people).
So this fall I asked 22 membership owners what’s working to grow their memberships right now. Some of them launch once a year and some keep the doors open all the time, a few have been at it for less than a year and a few for five-plus years… and a handful of ideas kept coming up across the board. It was pretty validating to see that they’re the same things I’ve been preaching on this blog for years!
Here’s the short version: the membership owners who are growing right now are simplifying what’s inside their memberships, letting people experience the membership before they buy, selling with email instead of relying on launches or social media, and treating retention as part of growth. Below is my take on each one, plus a peek at what the contributors had to say about it.
Adding more to your membership won’t make people stay
A simpler membership is easier to sell and easier to stay in. I’ve been saying for years that more content doesn’t mean more value, and that the fastest way to make a membership harder to use (and harder to sell) is to keep piling things into it.
When members can’t keep up, they start feeling like they’re paying for stuff they never get to, and that’s usually right around when they cancel. Styled Stock Society grew to over 10,000 members on one core thing and I wrote about how to streamline your membership in this blog post: Simplify Your Membership Content Without Losing Value.
This ended up being the biggest theme across all 22 membership owners that I asked, with 41% of contributors saying that adding more to their membership made it worse.
Contributor after contributor said adding more calls, trainings and bonuses backfired, and several of them cut back to one core thing and saw fewer cancellations along with a much smaller workload! The ones who still add something new every month were clear that every addition needs a reason behind it (so add wisely).
Give people a taste before they commit
The easiest way to make joining feel like the obvious next step is to let people try the membership first. One of the things I always come back to is that your lead magnet should give people a way to experience your membership before they join, in a way that fits your specific membership model. That looks pretty different for a content library than it does for a coaching-style membership. (If you’re not sure what type of lead magnet makes sense for your membership, my Membership Lead Magnet Matchmaker will help you out, and it’s free!)
For a lot of membership owners, giving people a “taste” of your membership looks like a free live event like a masterclass, a workshop, a get-it-done session, or a challenge. When someone spends an hour doing the thing with you, joining feels like the obvious next step instead of a separate decision they have to talk themselves into.
Social media is less of a priority
You don’t need to post every day to grow a membership. Styled Stock Society grew on Google and Pinterest traffic that kept finding it years after I published something, and that’s a big part of why I talk about growth as build, borrow or buy in How to Grow a Membership Site Without Burnout. Building is your own content, borrowing is getting in front of someone else’s audience, and buying is ads. Social media is only one piece of the build bucket, and it’s the piece that asks you to show up every day for posts that stop getting seen within a day or two.
Over a quarter (27%) of contributors have pulled way back from social media or quit it completely, and most of them moved that time into email and collaborations, with 36% now growing by getting in front of someone else’s audience through bundles, summits, podcast guesting, JV webinars and affiliate programs. If social is eating your week, here’s what I’d do: pick one borrow strategy and give it a few months before you judge it. Even one podcast guest spot a month or one bundle a quarter is plenty to start with!
Launches are optional
I’ve been saying for a longggg time that you don’t have to launch to grow a membership, my membership has been open for 365 days / year ever since it first launched! What’s essential when you’re not relying on launches is having a sales funnel that invites people to join on an ongoing basis.
Eighteen of the membership owners I asked (82%) run evergreen memberships, meaning their doors are open year-round, and several went out of their way to say they disagree with the advice that you HAVE to open and close the cart. A couple used to launch and stopped because the launches were stressful and the results were hard to predict from one round to the next, while a few others still get great results from waitlist launches or a once-a-year sales window (and that’s fine too!).

Email is essential for selling
I help membership owners build evergreen email sequences, so I’m obviously biased, but I’ve believed for years that email is THE thing that sells your membership even when you’re offline. If you’re sending emails that aren’t converting to new members, you could probably read this blog post on How to Sell Your Membership With Email, since sending emails and selling with email are two very different things.
Once you’re ready to build something that runs without you, you’ve got to make sure that your lead magnet connects to a sales sequence (this is a basic funnel!) so when people discover you / your membership online, there’s a clear path for them to join.
Retention is a growth strategy
A member you keep is one you don’t have to replace next month, which is why I’ve always said retention is a key part of growing your membership. I recommend looking at when people usually cancel (month two? month six?) and making sure that you have multiple touchpoints before that happens. Whether it’s a check-in email, a reminder of what they haven’t used yet, or an offer for more support, you want to make sure that you’re clearly communicating the value of your membership on an ongoing basis
Membership Growth FAQs
What’s the difference between an evergreen membership and an open/close membership?
An evergreen membership is open to new members all year, while an open/close membership only accepts new members during set enrollment windows, usually tied to a launch. Evergreen memberships typically rely on a sales funnel to bring members in continuously. Most of the 22 successful membership owners I asked run on evergreen, and it’s the model I recommend to most of my clients.
Can you grow a membership without social media?
You can, and plenty of membership owners are doing it. Over a quarter of the membership owners I asked have pulled way back from social media or quit it completely, and they’re growing through email, collaborations and searchable content that keeps getting found long after it’s published, like blog posts and YouTube videos.
How long should I test a membership growth strategy before switching?
I’d give any new strategy at least 90 days before deciding whether it’s working, since most strategies take a few months to show results. One contributor said most of her strategies didn’t pan out because she moved on before giving them enough time, and I think a lot of membership owners can relate to that!
Different things work for different people
I am never going to be a membership strategist who tells you that there’s one “right” way to grow because I know that different things work for different people and different types of memberships and different audiences.
Of course, there are things I can recommend as “best practices” and I’m always happy to share what worked for me and what I’m seeing work for other membership owners!
If you want to see how 22 membership owners are growing their memberships right now, Membership Growth, Unfiltered is free through November 20th. You’ll get the PDF, an interactive version you can filter by question, and a free resource from every contributor.
